Conventional Reel vs Spinning Reel – Which is best For you

ByM Bilal
PinLinkedIn
conventional reel vs spinning reel

Regarding fishing, the choice of reel can make a big difference in your overall experience. Two of the most common reels are the conventional reel and the spinning reel, each with advantages and disadvantages. When the question is about conventional reel vs spinning reel, the choice depends mainly on your fishing style and what type of fish you are targeting.

Ultimately, the choice between a conventional reel and a spinning reel comes down to personal preference and the type of fishing you plan to do. By considering the pros and cons of each type of reel, you can choose the one that best fits your needs and fishing style. We have taken it upon ourselves to unravel the mysteries behind these two fishing gear giants.

In this article, we will compare two different reels and also give a detail about the differences and similarities, which will make it easier to understand

Importance of choosing the right reel for your fishing style:

Choosing the right reel for your fishing style ensures a successful and enjoyable fishing experience. A reel unsuited to your fishing style can make casting difficult, reduce accuracy, and even cause you to lose fish. For example, using a spinning reel for heavy-duty saltwater fishing may result in line tangles or the reel being unable to handle the weight of the fish.

Conversely, using a conventional reel for finesse fishing or targeting smaller fish may make the setup feel clunky and challenging to manage. By choosing a suitable reel, you can achieve greater accuracy, improve your chances of hooking and landing fish, and enhance your fishing experience. So when considering a conventional reel vs spinning reel, it’s crucial to consider factors such as the type of fish you plan to target, the techniques you will use, and your experience level when selecting the right reel.

Conventional Reels:

Before you choose a reel, let’s know about conventional reels and their working. 

What are conventional reels:

Conventional reels, also known as baitcasting reels, are fishing reels designed for experienced anglers who require precision and control. These reels feature a spool that rotates perpendicular to the rod, allowing for greater accuracy and longer casts. They are often used for targeting larger fish or in saltwater environments, where heavier lines and larger lures are needed.

 Conventional reels require some skill and may take some practice to master, but once learned, they can provide high control and accuracy. They are ideal for anglers who prioritise precision and control over ease of use.

How do they work:

Conventional reels utilize a spool that rotates perpendicularly to the rod as the angler casts their line. The spool is mounted on an axle and turned by a handle attached to a gear system. The gear system amplifies the power of the angler’s cranking motion, allowing for greater control and precision when casting and retrieving the line.

 The level-wind mechanism on a conventional reel helps to distribute the line evenly across the spool and prevents tangling. The reel’s drag system helps control the tension on the line and prevents the line from breaking when a fish is hooked. Overall, the design of conventional reels allows for greater accuracy and control when fishing for larger, more challenging fish.

Power and Weakness of Conventional Reels:

old style reel

Conventional reels are popular among experienced anglers, but like any fishing equipment, they have strengths and weaknesses. These reels offer greater precision and control but can be more challenging than others.

Powers:

Conventional reels are potent tools that offer a range of benefits for experienced anglers. These reels are designed to provide greater accuracy, power, and control for targeting larger fish and challenging environments. You can have the following power points with a conventional reel.

  • Greater accuracy: Conventional reels are designed for precision and control, allowing anglers to make accurate casts and easily target specific areas.
  • Power and control: The gear system on conventional reels provides greater power and control, allowing anglers to handle heavier lines and larger fish.
  • Versatility: Conventional reels are suitable for various fishing applications, from freshwater bass fishing to saltwater trolling for larger species.
  • Longer casts: The perpendicular spool design of conventional reels allows for longer casts than other reel types, making them ideal for covering large water areas.
  • Line capacity: Conventional reels typically have a more extensive line capacity than other reel types, allowing anglers to use heavier lines and target larger fish.
  • Durability: Conventional reels are built to withstand heavy use and are designed to last for years with proper maintenance, making them a reliable choice for serious anglers.

Weakness:

As there are some benefits associated with any product, there are also some problems. You must be aware of them to face any situation properly.

  • Learning curve: One of the main weaknesses of conventional reels is that they can be challenging to use, particularly for novice anglers. The mechanics of the reel require a level of skill and experience to master, which can be intimidating for some anglers.
  • Backlash and tangles: Another area for improvement of conventional reels is that they can be more prone to backlash and tangles if not used properly. The high-speed spool rotation and lack of a built-in line pickup mechanism can lead to line tangles, which can be frustrating and time-consuming to fix.
  • Cost: Conventional reels can be more expensive than other reels, making them less accessible to budget-conscious anglers. High-quality conventional reels can cost several hundred dollars, a significant investment for some anglers. Additionally, maintenance and repairs can add up over time, making conventional reels a more expensive choice in the long run.
See also  1 Piece vs 2 Piece Fishing Rod: Choose an Excellent Rod

Spinning Reels:

After the conventional reel, let’s move on to a spinning reel and understand what they are and how they work.

What are spinning reels:

Spinning reels are a popular type of fishing reel that is designed for ease of use and versatility. These reels have a fixed spool that rotates around the rod axis as the angler casts and retrieves their line. Spinning reels are typically easier to learn and use than conventional reels, making them a popular choice among novice anglers. 

They are also suitable for various fishing applications, from freshwater fishing for bass or trout to saltwater fishing for smaller species like snook or redfish. Spinning reels can be used with various lines and lures, making them versatile for anglers of all skill levels.

How do they work:

Spinning reels use a fixed spool that rotates around the rod axis as the angler casts and retrieves their line. The line is wound onto the spool, connected to a rotor spilling around a stationary spindle. As the handle is turned, the rotor spins, pulling the line off the spool and onto the fishing rod. 

Spinning reels typically have a bail mechanism that helps to guide the line onto the spool evenly, preventing tangles or snarls. The drag system on a spinning reel helps to control the tension on the line and prevent it from breaking when a fish is hooked. Overall, spinning reels are designed for ease of use and versatility, making them popular among anglers of all skill levels.

Power and weakness of spinning reels:

Now we will discuss the power points you achieve and the weaknesses you could face with spinning reels during your fishing experience.

Powers:

The following points can give you an edge during your fish fight.

  • Easy to use: One of the main benefits of spinning reels is their ease of use. The fixed spool design and intuitive mechanics make them popular among novice anglers, as they require less skill and practice to use effectively.
  • Versatility: Spinning reels are suitable for a wide range of fishing applications, from freshwater fishing for trout to saltwater fishing for larger species like snook or redfish. They can be used with various lines and lures, making them versatile for anglers of all skill levels.
  • Smooth drag system: Spinning reels typically have a smooth and reliable drag system that helps to control the tension on the line and prevent it from breaking when a fish is hooked. It makes them ideal for targeting larger fish that require a more nuanced approach.
  • Long casts: The fixed spool design of spinning reels allows for longer casts than other reel types, making them ideal for covering large water areas.
  • Affordability: Spinning reels are generally more affordable than other reels, making them popular among budget-conscious anglers. They offered a good balance of performance and affordability, making them an excellent choice for novice and experienced anglers.

Weaknesses:

Consider the following weaknesses before they spoil your fishing trip.

  • Limited power: Spinning reels may offer a different level of power and control than conventional reels, making them less suitable for targeting larger or stronger fish.
  • Line twist: Spinning reels can be more prone to line twists, which can cause tangles and affect casting distance and accuracy. It can be especially problematic when using lighter lines or finesse techniques.
  • Line capacity: Spinning reels may have limited line capacity compared to other reels, which can be a disadvantage when targeting larger species requiring heavier lines.

Comparison of Conventional and Spinning Reels:

Source

Now for a better understanding, we will pick up two reels and compare them; we will look at their differences, similarities, and joint problems about them that can give us a realistic picture of how a conventional reel vs a spinning reel will be.

See also  Fly Fishing vs Baitcasting : 2 Legendary Styles For Fishing

PENN Squall II Star Drag Conventional Fishing Reel:

The PENN Squall II Star Drag Conventional Fishing Reel is a high-quality, versatile reel designed for saltwater fishing. It features a durable graphite frame, side plates, stainless steel bearings, and gears for reliable performance. The reel’s star drag system allows for precise adjustments to the drag pressure, making it suitable for targeting a wide range of fish species. 

It also features a line capacity ring to help anglers track their remaining lines. With its smooth and consistent performance, the PENN Squall II Star Drag Conventional Fishing Reel is an excellent choice for experienced anglers who demand the best from their gear.

Penn Spin-fisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel:

The Penn Spinfisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel is a high-quality, versatile reel designed for saltwater fishing. It features a whole metal body, side plate construction for durability, and a sealed drag system to keep saltwater out and prevent corrosion. The reel also boasts an HT-100 carbon fiber drag system, which delivers smooth and consistent drag performance.

 With its CNC gear technology, the Penn Spinfisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel offers exceptional cranking power and torque, making it suitable for targeting a wide range of fish species. It also features a line capacity ring to help anglers track their remaining lines. Overall, the Penn Spinfisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel is a top-of-the-line reel that delivers excellent performance in any saltwater fishing situation.

Differences & Similarities between the two types of reel:

Now whenever you compare two products, the similarities and differences are essential to make any decision. Following differences and similarities will be very helpful for your understanding and decision-making.

Similarities:

Following are the similarities in both reels.

  • Both reels are manufactured by PENN, a well-respected brand in the fishing industry known for producing high-quality and durable fishing gear.
  • Both reels are designed for saltwater fishing applications, making them suitable for targeting a wide range of fish species in the ocean.
  • Both reels feature a line capacity ring, allowing anglers to keep track of their remaining line and adjust their fishing strategy accordingly.
  • Both reels use advanced drag systems to provide a smooth and consistent performance when fighting fish, making them suitable for targeting larger and stronger fish species.
  • Both reels offer a good balance of performance and affordability, making them an excellent choice for novice and experienced anglers.

Differences:

Following are the differences both reels come with.

  • The Spinfisher VI is a spinning reel, while the Squall II is a conventional reel, meaning they have different designs and construction.
  • The Squall II targets larger and stronger fish, while the Spinfisher VI is better for lighter applications.
  • The Squall II offers more accuracy and control for casting, while the Spinfisher VI offers a smoother and more consistent drag system.
  • The Spinfisher VI features a whole metal body and side plate construction, while the Squall II is graphite.
  • The Squall II has a star drag system, while the Spinfisher VI uses a sealed drag system, making them different in how the drag is adjusted and maintained.

Maintenance and Care Comparison of both Fishing Reels:

fishing reel on river

Maintenance and care are of immense importance for long-term and reliable use. With the following comparison, you can better decide on reel selection for your fishing needs.

Maintenance comparison:

Maintenance comparison between the Penn Spinfisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel and PENN Squall II Star Drag Conventional Fishing Reel:

  • Both reels require regular cleaning and lubrication to prevent corrosion and ensure smooth performance.
  • The Squall II’s star drag system requires occasional adjustment and maintenance to keep it functioning correctly, while the Spinfisher VI’s sealed drag system requires less maintenance.
  • The Squall II’s graphite frame and side plates are more susceptible to scratches and damage than the Spinfisher VI’s complete metal construction, requiring more careful handling.
  • Both reels require periodic replacement of the line to prevent wear and damage to the spool and line guides.
  • Proper storage in a dry and protected environment is essential for both reels to prevent damage from exposure to saltwater and other environmental factors.

Common problems and troubleshooting tips:

Penn Spinfisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel:

Here are three common problems that can occur with the Penn Spinfisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel:

  • Line twist: Spinfisher VI can be prone to line twists, which can cause tangles and knots in the line. It can happen when the line is retrieved at an angle, causing it to wrap around the spool. To prevent line twists, anglers should use high-quality fishing line and ensure it is spooled on the reel correctly.
  • Drag system issues: While Spinfisher VI’s sealed drag system requires less maintenance than other reels, it can still develop issues over time. Problems with the drag system can cause the reel to lock up or fail to provide enough resistance, making it difficult to reel in fish.
  • Corrosion: Like all saltwater fishing reels, Spinfisher VI is susceptible to corrosion from exposure to saltwater and other environmental factors. Corrosion can cause the reel to seize, leading to issues with the drag system and other components. Regular cleaning and maintenance can help prevent corrosion, but over time it can still become a problem if not correctly cared for.
See also  Difference Between Fishing and Fly Fishing : Battle of 2023

PENN Squall II Star Drag Conventional Fishing Reel common problems: 

Here are three common problems that can occur with the PENN Squall II Star Drag Conventional Fishing Reel:

  • Line issues: The Squall II can develop problems with the line, such as line twists and tangles, making it difficult to cast and reel in fish. It can happen if the line is not spooled on the reel correctly or needs to be changed more frequently.
  • Drag system issues: The Squall II’s star drag system requires more maintenance than other drag systems and can develop issues over time. Problems with the drag system can cause the reel to lock up or fail to provide enough resistance, making it difficult to reel in fish.
  • Corrosion: As with all saltwater fishing reels, the Squall II is susceptible to corrosion from exposure to saltwater and other environmental factors. Corrosion can cause the reel to seize, leading to issues with the drag system and other components. Regular cleaning and maintenance can help prevent corrosion, but over time it can still become a problem if not correctly cared for.

Troubleshooting tips for both reels:

Here are three troubleshooting tips that apply to both the Penn Spinfisher VI Spinning Fishing Reel and the PENN Squall II Star Drag Conventional Fishing Reel:

  • Check the line: If you are experiencing issues with casting or reeling in fish, check the line for tangles, knots, or signs of wear. If necessary, replace the line or re-spool the reel.
  • Clean and lubricate the reel: Both reels require regular cleaning and lubrication to keep them working smoothly. Remove any dirt, debris, or salt buildup from the reel with a soft brush and mild soap solution. Lubricate the moving parts with reel oil or grease as the manufacturer recommends.
  • Inspect the drag system: Both reels feature a drag system that can develop issues over time, causing the reel to lock up or fail to provide enough resistance. Disassemble the drag system and inspect the drag washers for wear or damage. Replace any worn or damaged parts and reassemble the drag system.

Final thoughts and recommendations:

The Conventional Reel and the Spinning Reel have unique strengths and advantages, catering to different fishing styles and preferences. The Conventional Reel excels in precision and control, making it an excellent choice for experienced anglers seeking versatility in various fishing techniques.

Ultimately, the best fishing reel for you depends on your skill level, target species, preferred fishing techniques, budget, and personal preferences. By carefully considering these factors and maintaining your chosen reel properly, you can enjoy countless successful fishing adventures for years to come.


So, whether you opt for the Conventional Reel’s precision or the Spinning Reel’s efficiency, may your fishing endeavors be filled with excitement, memorable catches, and the joy of being in harmony with nature.

FAQs!!

  1. Are conventional reels better than spinning?

    There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, as conventional and spinning reels have strengths and weaknesses. The better choice depends on personal preference and fishing style.

  2. Which type of reel is best?

    There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, as the best reel type depends on the angler’s fishing application and personal preference. Factors such as target species, fishing technique, and budget should be considered when choosing a reel.

  3. Are conventional reels meant for casting?

    Yes, conventional reels are designed for casting and are generally better suited for long-range casting and heavy-duty fishing. However, they require more skill and practice to use effectively than spinning reels.

  4. Do conventional reels cast further than spinning?

    Not necessarily. While conventional reels are often used for long-range casting, spinning reels can also achieve impressive distances. The technique and skill of the angler also play a significant role in casting distance.

  5. Which type of reel is best?

    There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, as the best reel type depends on the angler’s fishing application and personal preference. Factors such as target species, fishing technique, and budget should be considered when choosing a reel.

PinLinkedIn

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *